Located at 146 Front Street West, Side Piece Slice Shop is tucked down an alley beneath The Loose Moose, next to The Antler Room. The entrance is easy to miss, but the smell of fresh pizza might lead you right to it.
The idea came from three friends: chef Gord Mackie, Brooklyn-trained pizzaiolo Johnathan Urquilla, and Martin Mazur. Inspired by a pizza trip to New York, the trio set out to bring classic New York-style slices to downtown Toronto. According to the shop, it all started with a shared love of pizza and a few pints.
Recommended Articles
Toronto’s St. Lawrence Market is bringing back its free outdoor holiday market with 75+ weekend vendors
A magical Scandinavian Christmas market with gnomes and bonfires is returning near Toronto this November
The shop serves 18-inch pies with oversized New York-style slices, made with hand-tossed dough fermented for 72 hours. According to Streets of Toronto, slices range from $4.75 to $6, while whole pies cost $27 to $32.
Classic options include three-cheese New Yorker, vodka sauce, Margherita, burrata, and Super Pepperoni. More adventurous choices feature bacon and pickle on a sesame crust with green garlic ranch, spicy soppressata with smoked caciocavallo and pineapple, and lemon ricotta with stracciatella and black pepper.
Side Piece Slice Shop’s reported hours are 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. daily, or until the dough runs out. After selling out on opening day, the newcomer is giving Toronto pizza lovers another spot to grab an oversized New York-style slice.
The Details
- Where: 146 Front Street West, Toronto (beneath The Loose Moose, next to The Antler Room)
- Opened: November 5, 2026
- Reported hours: Daily, 11 a.m.–11 p.m. (subject to dough availability)
- Price: $4.75 – $6 per slice; $27 – $32 for an 18-inch pizza
- Website: Side Piece Pizza